⚖️Recast or Refinance? Don't Guess.

Written By Jennifer Patel

You just came into some extra cash. Maybe you sold another property, received a bonus, inherited money, or simply have savings sitting in the bank.

Now you're wondering: Should I recast my mortgage or refinance it?

While both can lower your monthly payment, they work very differently.

What Is a Mortgage Recast?

A recast allows you to make a large lump-sum payment toward your principal balance. Your lender then recalculates your monthly payment based on the new, lower loan balance.

The key: Your interest rate and loan term stay exactly the same.

Example:

You owe $400,000 on a mortgage with a 6.5% interest rate.

You receive a $50,000 bonus and apply it directly to the principal.

After a recast, your loan balance drops to $350,000, and your lender recalculates your payment based on the lower balance.

✅ Lower monthly payment
✅ Keep your current interest rate
✅ No new loan required

Typical Costs

Most lenders charge a recast fee, usually between $150 and $500.

What Is a Refinance?

A refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a brand-new loan.

This allows you to:

  • Lower your interest rate

  • Change your loan term

  • Remove mortgage insurance

  • Pull cash out of your home's equity

  • Add or remove a borrower

Example:

You currently have a 7% interest rate.

Rates drop to 5.75%.

Refinancing into a new loan at 5.75% could significantly reduce your payment and lower the total interest paid over the life of the loan.

Typical Costs

Refinancing usually costs 2%–5% of the loan amount, though lender credits can sometimes offset some or all of those costs.

When a Recast Might Make Sense

A recast could be a good option if:

  • You have a large lump sum to apply toward your mortgage.

  • Your current interest rate is already attractive.

  • You want a lower payment without restarting your loan term.

  • You recently sold a home and want to apply the proceeds to your new mortgage.

Pros

✔ Lower monthly payment
✔ Low fees
✔ Keeps existing interest rate
✔ No appraisal required in most cases

Cons

✘ Requires a large principal payment
✘ Doesn't lower your interest rate
✘ Not available on every loan program

When a Refinance Might Make Sense

A refinance may be worth considering if:

  • Current rates are lower than your existing rate.

  • You want to shorten your loan term.

  • You need cash for renovations, debt consolidation, or other expenses.

  • You want to remove mortgage insurance.

Pros

✔ Potentially lower interest rate
✔ Multiple loan options
✔ Can reduce total interest paid
✔ Access to equity through cash-out refinance

Cons

✘ Higher closing costs
✘ New loan application and underwriting process
✘ May restart your mortgage timeline

Which Is Better?

Neither option is automatically better—it depends on your goal.

Want a lower payment and already have a great rate? A recast may be the winner.

Want a lower rate, different loan term, or access to equity? A refinance could make more sense.

The best strategy often comes down to the numbers, which is why it's important to review both options before making a decision.

Ready to Run the Numbers?

Every mortgage is different. Before you send a big principal payment or jump into a refinance, let's compare the options and see which one saves you the most money.

📲 Reach out and I'll help you determine whether a recast, refinance, or neither is the right move for your situation.

Jennifer Patel
Next

Cromford Report