🏗️ Builder Confidence: Stuck in Neutral, Waiting for a Spark

🔗Find more here on MND

The latest🔗 NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index shows builder confidence has dipped to 32 in August 2025, marking yet another month below the break-even point of 50. Sentiment has been stuck in the low 30s since May, a clear sign that high borrowing costs and economic uncertainty continue to chill the housing market.

Builders are trying to spark activity by cutting prices and piling on sales incentives, but affordability pressures and regulatory hurdles are proving tough to overcome. While there’s some cautious optimism for the months ahead, the industry is still waiting for a meaningful shift in rates, costs, or policy that could reignite momentum

📉 What’s Going On

Confidence among homebuilders isn’t just low—it’s stubbornly low. 🔗August’s HMI reading of 32 slipped from July’s 33, and the index has now hovered in this range for months. To put that in perspective, any reading below 50 means more builders see conditions as “poor” than “good.” Right now, most are clearly struggling to feel optimistic.

Builders report that current sales conditions are sliding while six-month expectations have flattened. Even prospective buyer traffic, which nudged slightly higher, remains historically weak at 22. Simply put: foot traffic may be trickling back, but it’s far from a rush.

💸 Builders Under Pressure

To keep deals alive, many 🔗builders are turning to incentives. Roughly 37% reported cutting prices in August, with average reductions around 5%. Meanwhile, two-thirds are offering sales perks like free upgrades or mortgage rate buydowns, the highest incentive rate since the pandemic.

Still, affordability remains the biggest hurdle. Elevated mortgage rates continue to sideline buyers, while costs for labor and materials haven’t eased as much as hoped. Add in 🔗policy and regulatory hurdles, from zoning delays to land-use restrictions, and builders find themselves squeezed from both ends.

🔍 Why It Matters

Low builder confidence doesn’t just affect builders—it ripples through the entire housing market. Fewer new homes mean tighter supply, which in turn keeps prices higher even as demand softens. For buyers, that creates a frustrating paradox: too few homes and mortgages that feel out of reach.

From an economic standpoint, housing is a major driver of growth, and sluggish construction weighs on local economies. Builders emphasize that meaningful improvement will require more than just lower mortgage rates—it will also take regulatory relief and more stable input costs.

📊 What to Watch

The next few months hinge on several factors. Mortgage rates remain the most immediate pressure point. 🔗If the Fed signals easing, affordability could improve and confidence may rise. The labor market is another critical piece: steady jobs support buyer demand, while layoffs or rising unemployment could drag confidence lower.

On the cost side, builders are watching for relief in materials and supply chains. And perhaps most importantly, they’re pressing policymakers for reforms in land use and permitting—structural shifts that could help unlock more affordable development.

🐼 Mama Bear’s Take

Builder confidence may be soft, but don’t mistake that for permanent gloom. Buyers are still out there, and when conditions shift—whether through lower rates, better incentives, or policy changes—demand could roar back quickly.

For now, the smart play is to track builder incentives and help clients take advantage where they can. When the spark comes, those prepared will be the first to move.

📌 Let’s set up a time to talk now so you are ready for the next steps when the time is right.